I’m going to take a deep breath, count to
ten, and try very hard to pretend that the people who are running the country
are grown-ups. I’m going to resist all Shakespearean allusions and attempt to
negotiate a path through the wreckage that now passes for the British political
scene.
So here’s what matters above all. We need a
new prime minister, and whoever it turns out to be – it may even be someone who
has been neither accused of, nor the victim of, rank treachery -- will have two
over-riding duties: to respect the result of the Brexit referendum and to get
the best deal available for the UK’s new relationship with our former EU
partners.
I am surprised at the number of my friends
– who, like me, were dismayed by the referendum result – who still think that
there may be some way to undo what they regard as a disastrous outcome.
Constitutionally, they are right – the referendum has no standing in law, and
MPs are under no legal obligation to take any notice of it.
But, guys, come on. Seventeen million
people voted for Britain to leave the EU, and even if some of them were woefully
misinformed, or ignorant, or bigots, or thought they were just sticking two
fingers up to David Cameron, a vote is a vote. There is nothing in the theory
of modern democracy that says only the choices of well-informed voters with
university degrees will count. Yes, the result will damage the UK’s future
prospects – that’s our view, anyway – but a vote has been cast and to ignore it
or seek to wriggle out of the consequences would simply fuel the anti-elite
rhetoric of UKIP and even less salubrious political groupings. Is that really
what you want?
So the task ahead is to minimise the damage
done and get the best deal possible out of Brussels. And, given that at this
time of grave national crisis, the country’s main opposition party has collapsed
into a writhing heap of irrelevance, the task will fall either to Theresa May
or to Michael Gove. (Yes, I know there used to be someone called Boris Johnson,
but he has vanished in a cloud of convoluted rhetoric and the most abject
display of political cowardice since David Miliband ducked out of challenging
Gordon Brown.)
May and Gove have history. Two years ago,
they were involved in an ugly Whitehall clash over who was doing a better job
of combatting Islamist extremism; the prime minister had to bang their heads
together and make them both sit on the naughty step. Gove is the more
ideological of the two and is not afraid of making enemies; May is tough and
pragmatic, a loner who ploughs her own furrow and gets on with the job.
Her supporters say she is just the person
the country needs to go head to head with Angela Merkel (who, like her, is the
uncharismatic daughter of a clergyman) and with other EU leaders to negotiate a
new deal for the UK. Her critics argue that she was against Brexit all along
and so can’t be trusted to abide by the spirit of the referendum result.
Gove has demonstrated a ruthless streak
that his owlish demeanour has kept largely hidden from public view. Having
previously complained that there were too many old Etonians at the top of the
Tory party, he has now reduced their number by two (Cameron and Johnson), so no
one will be able to accuse of him of lack of steel. And his high-profile
campaigning for a Leave vote (remember ‘People in this country have had enough
of experts’?) will undoubtedly endear him to many of the 150,000 Conservative
party activists in whose hands our future now lies.
With the Labour party thrashing about in
what may turn out to be its death throes, there is no point in calling for a
general election. After all, when Gordon Brown wrenched the keys to Number 10
from Tony Blair’s hands in 2007, there wasn’t even a leadership election – and
I cannot believe that even Jeremy Corbyn’s most fanatical supporters would
argue that he is the right man to lead the UK’s post-Brexit negotiations.
Labour MPs have proved themselves, yet
again, to be the world’s most incompetent political assassins. They assumed,
wrongly, that their leader would draw the obvious conclusions once he had
overwhelmingly lost a vote of confidence among his own MPs. But Jeremy Corbyn
has shown himself to be less decent, less honourable, and more arrogant than
his acolytes would have us believe. He would rather cling to the purity of his ideological
vision than step down for the good of his party. As a result, Britain is left
with a lame-duck prime minister and no functioning opposition as it faces its
gravest political crisis since the Suez debacle 60 years ago. No wonder so many
voters have so little respect for professional politicians.
Like all crises, this one will eventually
pass. But not before the economy has stuttered to a stand-still, the value of
the pound has fallen further (you’ll soon notice it if you’ve booked a holiday
in France or Spain this summer) and investors have started looking elsewhere.
It won’t be long before real people start losing real jobs. As Theresa May put
it: ‘Some [politicians] need to be
told that what the government does isn’t a game.’
The best we can hope
for, once the dust has settled, is a deal that takes us out of the EU while retaining
a close relationship with it: perhaps with less than total access to the single
market in return for less than total freedom of movement for EU nationals
coming to the UK. Theresa May will never be a heroine for those on the liberal
left, but even they might conclude that, given what’s on offer, she may be the
least bad potential prime minister we’re likely to get.